Clean Beauty Has No Legal Definition

The first post I ever wrote for this blog had “Clean Skincare” in the title. Since then I’ve spent a lot more time reading labels (it comes with importing skincare for a living), and along the way I learned that “clean” has no legal definition in the U.S. Neither does “natural,” and neither does “hypoallergenic.” With holiday gifting about to start, and the words on the front of the box about to do a lot of the selling, I wanted to lay out who checks them.

Why the Words on the Front Matter Less Than You Think

The FDA doesn’t approve cosmetic labels before a product goes on sale. In its own words, it “does not have the authority under the law for pre-market approval of cosmetic product labeling,” so getting the label right is left to the company. If a claim is misleading, it gets challenged after the fact, by the FDA, by the FTC (the agency that polices advertising), or by a customer with a lawyer.

So why should you care, beyond not wanting to overpay for a word? Because a word on the front can’t tell you what’s in the formula. Take a preservative called methylisothiazolinone (MI for short). It was legal in cosmetics on both sides of the Atlantic, and in the early 2010s it was showing up in more products and enough people were reacting to it that the American Contact Dermatitis Society named it Contact Allergen of the Year for 2013. European researchers later described an “epidemic” of contact allergy to it. The EU’s answer was to ban MI from leave-on products (anything you don’t rinse off) in 2017 and to cut the limit in rinse-off products like shampoo from 100 parts per million to 15. In the U.S., according to a report on North American allergy data, the federal government doesn’t restrict it.

A word like “clean” or “natural” on the front wouldn’t have told you whether a product had MI in it, because neither word is tied by law to any list of ingredients. The ingredient list did tell you, since the law requires it to name every ingredient. (That only helps if you know what you’re looking for, which is what step 4 at the end is about.)

“Clean” Is a Retailer’s Word

No federal law or FDA rule defines “clean.” In practice each retailer writes its own “made without” list (the ingredients its clean products can’t contain) and puts its own badge on whatever meets it, so clean at one store and clean at another are two different lists. In 2024 a shopper sued a large beauty retailer, arguing that its clean badge implied products with no synthetic or harmful ingredients at all. A federal court in New York dismissed the main claim, on the reasoning that the retailer had published what its badge meant and a reasonable shopper couldn’t read more into it than that. So the word means whatever the company using it says it means, and the published list is the thing to read.

“Natural” and “Organic”

The FDA says it “has not defined the term ‘natural’” for cosmetics, and it has no definition of “organic” either. Organic does have one real anchor, the USDA’s National Organic Program (the same one behind the seal on your groceries). A cosmetic made from agricultural ingredients can carry the USDA Organic seal if at least 95 percent of its ingredients, not counting water and salt, are organically produced.

“Natural” has no anchor like that, but the FTC has drawn one line. In 2016 it charged five companies that advertised lotions, shampoos and sunscreens as “all natural” or “100% natural” when the formulas contained synthetic ingredients such as dimethicone and phenoxyethanol, and four of them settled. Phenoxyethanol is a common preservative, by the way, and plenty of the products we carry at Relterra list it, which is one reason we don’t call anything “all natural.”

“Hypoallergenic” and “Free From”

The FDA did try to define “hypoallergenic” once. Its 1975 rule would have made companies run comparative tests before using the word, but two cosmetics companies sued and in 1977 a federal appeals court threw the rule out. There’s been no federal standard since, and the FDA’s own page on the subject passes along the view of dermatologists that the term has “very little meaning.”

Europe goes further, and I think it has this one right. The European Commission’s guidance on cosmetic claims says “hypoallergenic” should only go on a product designed to minimize its allergenic potential, with data to back that up, and that even then the word doesn’t guarantee you won’t react. The same guidance takes on “free from” claims. Since July 2019 a brand selling in the EU shouldn’t advertise being free from an ingredient that’s already banned there (the example it gives is corticosteroids), and it discourages “free from parabens” because the claim runs down a whole group of ingredients, some of which the EU permits and considers safe as used.

Seals That Someone Audits

If a word has no definition, the closest substitute I know of is a certification seal, where somebody wrote down a standard and an independent body checks against it. The USDA Organic seal is one. These are three more I’d look for:

  • COSMOS is a European standard for organic and natural cosmetics, founded by five certification bodies including Ecocert in France and the Soil Association in the UK. To be labeled COSMOS Organic, the standard says at least 95 percent of a product’s physically processed plant ingredients (pressed oils, for example) must be organic, and at least 20 percent of the whole formula must be organic (10 percent for rinse-off products). Centifolia, the French brand we carry, has every one of its products certified COSMOS Organic by Ecocert.
  • NATRUE is another European label. It keeps out silicones, mineral oils and synthetic fragrances, and won’t let a brand use the seal unless at least 75 percent of its products are certified.
  • Leaping Bunny is about animal testing only. A brand commits to a cut-off date after which neither it nor its suppliers test on animals, and independent auditors check.

One caution: these seals certify where ingredients come from and how a product is made, which is a different question from whether it will suit your skin. An organically grown ingredient can still be one you react to (more on that in our post on fragrance labeling).

What to Check Instead

All of that being said, this is what I’d do in a store aisle or on a product page this season.

  1. Read the ingredient list before you read the front of the box. U.S. rules require ingredients to be listed in descending order, so whatever comes first is what there’s most of. Look for anything you already know you react to. For a name you don’t recognize, the EU’s public CosIng database will tell you what the ingredient is and what it does in a formula.
  2. Check the “Made in” line. It tells you which rulebook the formula was most likely written against. A product made in the EU for sale there was formulated under the EU’s prohibited list, which is far longer than the U.S. one (I wrote about that gap in 11 vs. 1,700).
  3. Find the company name and contact details on the label. Under the Modernization of Cosmetics Regulation Act of 2022 (MoCRA), the manufacturer, packer or distributor named on the label is the “responsible person,” and the label has to give you a way to reach them (an address, a phone number or a website) if you have a bad reaction. If I couldn’t tell who that was, I’d put the product back.
  4. If your skin is reactive, skip past “hypoallergenic” and scan the list for the specific ingredients you know give you trouble, then try anything new on a small patch of skin for a few days. Trying a product on your arm can help indicate what ingredients you might be allergic to. To be more precise and find the specific ingredients, ask a dermatologist about patch testing. Small amounts of dozens of common allergens, fragrance mixes and preservatives among them, are taped to your back for 48 hours, and the doctor checks your skin when the patches come off and again a few days later. The American Academy of Dermatology says expanded testing finds about 80 percent of allergens. It isn’t cheap (one review puts it at $500 to $2,500 before insurance), but you leave with ingredient names to look for, and after that the ingredient list gets a lot more useful.

Europe’s guidance tells companies what they should be able to prove before they call a product “hypoallergenic.” I’d like to see the FDA set the same kind of standard here. MoCRA was the biggest expansion of the FDA’s authority over cosmetics since 1938, so maybe that isn’t too much to hope for.

Cheers,

Chase

Founder of Relterra